Does Socialism Have a Chance in New York City?
Is New York City falling for socialism? Judging by headlines, it might seem that way. But TFP Student Action’s bold street campaign in Manhattan paints a very different picture.
On July 24, 2025, sixteen young TFP volunteers stood on the iconic steps of the New York Public Library on Fifth Avenue to peacefully oppose socialism and proclaim the timeless values of Christian civilization.
“Socialism is a Philosophy of Failure”
With two prominent banners—one reading “May God Protect America from Socialism”, and the other quoting Sir Winston Churchill’s famous words, “Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy; its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.”
TFP volunteers delivered a powerful message in the heart of the city. The lively demonstration featured bagpipes, handouts, and bold slogans shouted through megaphones, cutting through the city’s chaotic pace with clear conviction:
- “America is not Venezuela!”
- “Socialism kills the American dream!”
- “What does socialism create? Slaves, thieves, and bums.”
- “What does socialism give the poor? Equal poverty and equal misery.”
- “The best remedy for poverty is Christian charity and private property.”
- “Stop socialism in our nation and restore the glory of Christian Civilization.”
Socialism denies the right to private property, contradicts the moral order established by God, and overlooks mankind’s calling to exercise responsible stewardship over creation.
By promoting egalitarianism that rejects legitimate differences in talents, vocations, and contributions, socialism stifles authentic progress and the flourishing of individuals according to the unique gifts entrusted to them by God. In short, socialism makes social harmony impossible.
Immigrants Not Fooled by Socialism
Many passersby, especially immigrants who fled socialist regimes, enthusiastically supported the campaign. Russians, Poles, Romanians, and Venezuelans approached TFP volunteers to share their painful experiences and warn against repeating history.
A Cuban man, visibly emotional, embraced a TFP member and said, “Socialism destroyed my country. Thank you for standing up.”
One Chinese woman, collecting signatures against the Chinese Communist Party, couldn’t speak much English—but she understood enough to smile and nod in support.
Leftist Logic and Misfires
Not everyone engaged honestly. Some responded with tired clichés like, “Jesus was a socialist,” or insults, like calling a black TFP volunteer a “white boy.”
Others tried the usual tactics: “You’re all men!”—a line used by feminists to silence pro-life men. But nobody understood why liberals employed this line regarding the topic of socialism.
One leftist rejected a flyer titled 10 Reasons to Reject socialism, shouting, “I don’t take things from fascist Nazis!” Ironically, few today seem to realize that “Nazi” stands for National Socialist German Workers’ Party.
New Yorkers for True Freedom
Despite the city’s liberal reputation, countless New Yorkers welcomed the campaign. Many took extra flyers to distribute, applauded, or joined in prayer.
“I agree with you on every point,” said one woman. “God bless you. Never stop speaking the truth.”
In a thick New York accent, two locals commented: “We hate socialism.”
Even in NYC, Socialism Doesn’t Sell
Despite New York’s many challenges, TFP Student Action’s outreach proved that the truth is still attractive—even here. When socialism is exposed for what it is—a failed, immoral system condemned by ten Popes—it loses its appeal.
New Yorkers, like Americans everywhere, want a truly free nation—under God, rooted in tradition, family, and private property.